‘Leg-breaker’ – Premier League release statement as James Tarkowski avoids red card in Merseyside derby
The PGMOL has acknowledged that Everton defender James Tarkowski should have been shown a red card on Wednesday night, talkSPORT understands.
The Toffees captain can count himself lucky he wasn't given an early bath in his side's 1-0 defeat to Liverpool - having left midfielder Alexis Mac Allister in agony over what has been described as a 'leg-breaking' challenge.
3
In the 11th minute at Anfield, the England international slid in to stop Mac Allister from getting to the ball first outside of Everton's box.
But with his follow through, the ex-Burnley man caught the 2022 World Cup winner high up on his leg.
Referee Sam Barrott instantly brandished a yellow card as concerned Liverpool players crowded around their stricken teammate.
But despite Paul Tierney on VAR duty taking a look, he refused to send the match official to the pitchside monitor for a second opinion.
READ MORE FOOTBALL NEWS
Speaking on Sky Sports commentary, a bewildered Gary Neville said: "That's a potential leg breaker."
Before adding: "You do not need to follow through like with such force, and it's high. Very lucky."
Meanwhile talkSPORT co-host Jamie O'Hara took to social media to post: "Tarkowski is one hundred percent a red card.
"I can’t believe VAR have let that go."
Most read in Football
The Premier League were quick in taking to to release a statement as to why Tarkowski wasn't shown a straight red card.
The statement read: "The referee’s call of yellow card for a reckless foul by Tarkowski was checked by the VAR, with contact on the follow through after Tarkowski had played the ball deemed to be reckless."
3
3
However, talkSPORT understands the PGMOL has since acknowledged a review should have been recommended as the nature of the follow-through met the threshold for serious foul play.
For Tarkowski, it was his 63rd booking in the top-flight since making his Premier League debut during the 2016/17 season.
It is the joint most amount of yellow cards in the division without ever been shown a red card.
And for Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher, he simply cannot understand how Tarkowski didn't pick up his first Premier League red card.
The Sky pundit remarked: "In terms of the referee, he is in brilliant position. He has to see that. It is a shocking tackle and there should be no debate.
"It is an awful tackle. He knows what he is doing. Tarkowski has got previous as well, against Everton for Burnley.
Sean Dyche reveals his new job two months after Everton sacking
"The referee should give it on the pitch, but for Paul Tierney not to give that on VAR is shocking."
Meanwhile Everton icon Duncan Ferguson said in his half-time analysis: "There's no argument, it's a straight red. We noticed it right away.
"How they have not given the decision... it's a straight red. Absolutely.
"He knows what he is doing, back in our day you might have gotten away with that, because you've tackled and got the ball.
"But he knows what he is doing, he's come right through him and that could have been a leg-breaker.
"That's a straight red all day long. Maybe it's the referee's first [Merseyside] derby, who knows, maybe he's a bit nervous giving the decision.
"He should have been taken to the monitor, he was in a great position, he should have given the decision on the field, but it's a straight red."
While Everton breathed a sigh of relief after Tarkowski was allowed to remain on the pitch, they felt aggrieved over Diogo Jota's eventual winner.
The Portuguese forward scored the only goal of the game in the 57th minute after jinxing past two players before firing past Jordan Pickford.
But there are question marks as to whether the goal should have been given as Luis Diaz, who supplied the assist, was in an offside position prior Jota's goal.
Read More on talkSPORT
For Liverpool, their victory over their bitter rivals has taken them a step closer to lifting a second Premier League title after increasing their lead over Arsenal to 12 points.
As for Everton, they remain in 15th spot after extending their winless run to five matches.
Topics